Abstract:
This research mainly explores the differences between online and TV variety shows. If compared with TV variety shows, online variety shows pay more attention to innovation and entertainment, while TV variety shows focus on making meaningful content such as education and cultural output. At present, the rapid development of the Internet has also led to the increasing popularity of online variety shows. In addition, I interviewed a director who directed both online and TV variety shows and a scriptwriter of online variety shows as planned. They told me their professional opinions on online and TV variety shows and the content from their personal experience, which also provided help for my future career.
Introduction:
In China, online variety shows have become more and more popular with the development of the Internet. Its content has gradually become more diverse and more conform to public preferences. Although TV variety shows are making changes to attract more audiences, their limitations still cannot contend against online variety shows to some extent. By comparing and analysing online and TV variety shows’ content production, we can see the differences between them and the reason why online variety shows have become mainstream nowadays. To investigate the differences in content production between China online and TV variety shows in the Internet era, I will pay attention to academic articles as the theories to support and prove my statements and ideas. I also hope my research can contribute to the differences in content production between Chinese online and TV variety shows. And how the differences in content production affect their ratings and target audiences.
Problem analysis:
With the development of Internet technology, and the multiplication of the number of people using electronic devices, which meanings the increase of online variety shows is also justified.

According to this table, since 2017, the number of online variety shows has takeover that of TV variety shows, which means there are more and more people who would like to watch variety shows online rather than on TV. Aside from the fact of online variety shows can be watched anytime and anywhere, in terms of content production, online variety shows are more attractive to the audiences. For example, they are more entertaining, have more themes, more creativity, and follow the trend which can make the shows more diverse and amusing, but it also lacks cultural connotation in content production. TV variety shows may lack creativity, have repetitive and unitary contents. Therefore, the interest of me about it is more refer to find out the reasons why is the content production so different between online and TV variety shows and what is the difference. Next, I will analyse the difference between online and TV variety shows as well as their advantages and disadvantages based on those points that I mentioned above.
Innovation:
Compared with TV variety shows, online variety shows pay more attention to innovation. As Li (2021) stated that in recent years, online variety shows have been shown rapid development, with continuous innovation in the types, categories, and contents of programs. Innovation seems to be have become necessary for contemporary online variety shows. For example, when Who’s the murderer first appeared on the screen in 2016, it can be said that the appearance of this online variety show made the detective variety shows start a new perspective in China.

According to Tang (2020), Who’s the murderer breaks the conventional thinking of detective variety shows and expands the boundaries of variety shows because it took the board games (a popular element in recent years in China) on the screen, which is an innovative and integrated development of Chinese online variety shows. However, compared with online variety shows, TV variety shows lack continuous innovation and the program model is single, which can make the audience have a negative attitude to some extent, and reduce freshness about the programs and thus reduce attractions.

For instance, the program Singer attached to rely on “the power of music itself” to create a perfect music stage, so in this program only had the part of singer performed, and its lack of the story of singers as well as the content of their experiences. It indeed reflects the essence of music, but on the other hand, it also makes the program content more serious, professional, and weak of entertainment and highlight (Mao 2020). Although Singer had caused a great response and attract much attention at the beginning of its launch, due to the monotonous and unchangeable content over the years, such as almost no change in competition system, process, comments, and interaction, which is difficult to leave a distinct impression on the audience (Mao 2020). Therefore, online variety show indeed shows it has more creativity to attract more audiences if compared with a TV variety show, and innovative programs tend to be accompanied by more entertainment in their contents.
Entertainment:
According to the data from the White paper on China’s professional online content users, users who are under 30 years old prefer to watch online variety shows and online films, users who are aged between 30 and 39 years more prefer to watch online dramas (Liu 2021). The most fundamental motivation for users to watch online variety shows is to satisfy their entertainment needs, so entertainment seems to be one of the most important elements of the online variety. As Liu (2021) stated that online variety shows as a new form of entertainment program for young people based on the Internet platform, entertainment has become the main trend of its creation. For example, Mars Intelligence Agency is a popular online variety show in China in recent years, which is a lighthearted and gagging show with the use of Internet buzzwords.
This program also reflects some interjection and other pinyin words on their subtitle, such as “WOW, PIA, BOOM” and so on (Tang 2020). These indeed ensure the entertainment of a program and also make the young people more willing to watch such programs. However, in order to gain more attention, some online variety shows use exaggerated or even vulgar language which caused the uneven quality of program contents and convey wrong value orientation to young people (Liu 2021). Hence, online variety shows should keep the balance between entertainment and sociality to create excellent works with thought and depth, and to become the value guide of young people in the new era. In addition, the content of TV variety shows is indeed less entertaining than online variety shows. TV variety shows focus on edutainment and its content is influenced by many aspects, such as national policy, culture and so on (Li 2021). With the development of variety shows and society in China, the requirements of people for entertainment and variety shows are getting higher and higher, and they also wish the variety shows can sublimate their spiritual realm based on funny and relaxation.
Integration:
Due to the sharp rise of variety shows in China, there are many TV variety shows learned from online variety shows to make them more interested and attracted based on keeping their core value. For example, Tian Tian Xiang Shang is a very famous TV talk show in China. Its content is more in a popular style, usually about traditional culture and educational topics, but it uses a more relaxed and interesting way to convey culture, such as the hosts teased each other, play games and so on (Xie 2016).

This program is positioned to spread Chinese etiquette culture so that the audience can feel the traditional Chinese virtues in entertainment and laughter (Xie 2016). At the same time, online variety shows gradually began to convey positive energy to the audience while entertaining the public, leading to more in-depth content. As Who’s the murderer as the example, its virtual stories often dissect hot social issues, such as cyber violence, school bullying, child abuse, plastic surgery, and many different hot issues (Tang 2020). This program can guide the audience to think through its content and to warn the audience and give the correct guidance through the feelings of celebrity players. Therefore, online and TV variety shows are learning from each other’s advantages and developing in a positive direction.
Commercialization:
Sponsors are very important for a program, and the program also needs to provide certain exposure for the sponsors. But the amount of advertising on TV and online variety shows has a huge difference. For example, in the TV variety show Tian Tian Xiang Shang, the advertisement implantation uses a traditional way. The host usually uses oral broadcasting at the beginning of the program and there are sponsored advertisements during the program (Xie 2016). Such an appropriate number of advertisements will not affect the audience’s emotion while they watching, but the excessive commercialization of online variety shows will lead to the advertisements show everywhere, which will form a negative influence on the audience. Mars Intelligence Agency is a program that only has 50 minutes, but advertisements are full of the whole program, such as the opening, host broadcast, short video advertisements and so on. Moreover, the content of this program is also deeply influenced by advertisements, no matter what the guests talk about, they will be associated with the various advertisement (Xie 2016). Advertising plays a significant role in today’s variety shows, but from the perspective of the audiences, too many advertisements will make the shows too commercial.
Interview:
In order to explore the differences between the content of online and TV variety shows, I interviewed a director, Jia Chao and a scriptwriter, Wang Chenchen from the company where I worked as an intern. They not only explained to me the differences between online and TV variety shows at this stage, but also provided many professional suggestions to my question.
Question 1: What do you think of the development of variety shows now?
Jia Chao: “First of all, the development of this industry has been positive in recent years. Because there were more and more variety shows have appeared to the public, and have received lots of positive responses and discussion. Moreover, in terms of form and theme, there are more and more programs with different themes, such as detective theme, escape theme and our own company’s programs focusing on street dance, those are really popular in recent years, and those were not available in the early years. So, at this stage, a lot of variety shows are trying to innovate and to distinguish themselves from others, the rapid development of variety shows has indeed led to more and more shows of the same theme. “
Wang Chenchen: “In my profession, my job is to make program content that the audience love. Besides, with the increasing number of variety shows and their competitiveness, I am under a lot of pressure because I am afraid that the content of the show will not be liked by the audience. At the same time, I need to keep innovating, and I also need to make the content interesting. Because entertainment is also playing a vital role in this era. “
Question 2: Do you think there are any essential differences in content between online and TV variety shows?
Jia Chao: “Because I have directed both online and TV variety shows, there are indeed have some differences between them based on my experience, which is not only reflected in the recording process but also the post-production stage. First, the production of TV variety shows needs to be more rigorous, it can be entertaining but not too entertaining, which means it should be appropriate. But the online variety shows are fewer requirements if compare with TV variety shows, they need entertainment, and their content will be more interesting and have more themes. In the post-production, we also needed to add lots of network buzzwords to make the program funnier.
Wang Chenchen: “I think there are a lot of differences, but there are also some similarities. Although I am mainly responsible for the scriptwriter of online variety shows, I have also learned in my previous research about TV variety shows, I realised that TV variety shows indeed made their contents through teaching and entertainment. Therefore, I also acquired new knowledge from it and amplified and highlighted these meaningful contents in the program production. I think this is a key point that helps online variety shows become more successful and attractive. Because combining education with entertainment does have a positive impact on the public. “
Question 3: In this era of variety shows are everywhere, do you think you need to make any changes in content and form to attract more audiences?
Jia Chao: “Indeed, there are more and more variety shows now, not only online variety shows but also TV variety shows. I also find that many people have some opinions about the invariable content of the shows. So, we’re always looking for new ways to try to make the program more interesting. But its needs time, and we’re still finding our ways, and we’re working on it. So, I believe that we will create more novel and interesting content and forms in future programs. “
Wang Chenchen: “I think the first thing I need to do is to keep up with the trend, to find out what is a popular topic in the society, and then to integrate the events or themes that the audience are interested in into the program, so this is a way to ensure the program can always be attractive. In addition, it is also important to confirm the target audience, because the content needs to be adjusted and improved according to the preferences of the target audience, which is a necessary condition to improve the ratings of the program.”
Conclusion:
To sum up, the differences between online and TV variety shows are mainly reflected in that online variety shows pay more attention to innovation, entertainment, and the public’s preferences, while TV variety shows pay more attention to education and cultural transmission. But now online and TV variety shows are also learning from each other, aiming to combine innovation, entertainment, and meaningful content to provide the audiences with positive content. During the interview, I also confirmed the above points and got more relevant knowledge from the interviewees. This is good for my future career development.
Reflection:
First of all, I think analysing the differences between online and TV variety shows will help my future career a lot. After I understand the characteristics of online variety shows, I can create a program according to the points that I mentioned above such as innovation, entertainment, and novelty. Besides, I need to keep up with the hot topic and current events, understand what the public likes, and combine the program contents with those popular topics aims to better attract the potential target audience.
Online variety shows are really popular among young people. The contents are vital because it always follows the trend closely, and there are some online catchwords and some interesting jokes that arise in online variety shows, which always can resonate with young people, it also becomes a part of their daily conversation. Therefore, to be a successful director of online variety shows, I need to know what my target audience likes and what will attract their attention. I also need to make innovations in the content, so that the audiences can always feel that my program is interesting and fresh. This will keep them interested and watching my program.
However, the advertisement in the online variety shows does affect many people’s viewings experience. But it is inevitable according to what I have experiences in my internship. Why brands are willing to spend a lot of money to sponsor a program? The reason for it is to gain more exposure and attract more potential consumers. Personally, sometimes too much advertising can backfire because it really has a negative effect on the audience’s experience. For instance, the placement of advertisements is too awkward, or the continuous appearance of many times to cause the aversion of the audience. At the same time, I also learned to expose the advertisings naturally, such as using the sponsor’s projects as game props, or as a transition.
However, although TV variety shows may lag behind the online variety shows in some aspects, it is a good platform to pay attention to cultural connotations. Therefore, I am very willing to combine and integrate the characteristics of online and TV variety shows, like comprehensive and culture. I think it will contribute to the development of Chinese variety shows in the future. At the same time, it will also be vital to my future career, which will help me to make programs that are more in line with the aesthetic taste of the audience and rich in cultural conservation.
References:
Guanyan Report 2021, 2021 China Online Variety Industry Analysis Report – Industry status and Future Trend Research, Chinabaogao.
Li, YT 2021, “Analysis of the innovation ability of online variety shows from the perspective of audience”, Shengpingshijie, China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House.
Liu, H 2021, ‘Development strategy analysis of online variety shoes based on Mango TV”, Journal of News Research, Hunan, Changsha.
Mao, Y 2020, “A brief analysis on the innovation and development of variety shows from Singer and U can U say”, The Science Education Article Collects, Beijing.
Tang, Y 2020, “The bright spot analysis and prospect exploration of the online variety shows of detective game – the example of Who’s the murderer”, The Film, Communication University of China.
Xie, XQ , 2016, “On the difference of content production between Network variety shows and TV variety shows – the example of Mars Intelligence Agency and Tian Tian Xiang Shang”, The Journal of News Research, The university of Guang Zhou.
Figures:
Who’s the murderer: http://pic2.zhimg.com/v2-89b28bf0064178cd9995510eac4ef145_b.jpg
Singer: http://5b0988e595225.cdn.sohucs.com/images/20180202/0147d4280e00413f83ff4ff9548b
Mars Intelligence Agency: https://cf.shopee.tw/file/6607f7896117c3b46a86f9f9627fdc9e
Tian Tian Xiang Shang: http://5b0988e595225.cdn.sohucs.com/images/20200324/1839d5922f99



















People for inspecting a new apartment in Caulfield North, and waiting in a long queue. Photo by: Miao Zhang
High demand of people looking to rent in Caulfield North, concentrate mainly on January and May. Chart by: Miao Zhang